Dec 14, 1986 several plan to submit resolutions designed to kill poison pill defenses. The term poison pill usually refers to the defense a company establishes when a takeover is threatened. Using shareholder rights plans poison pills to fight. The company said on friday that it had extended a shareholder rights plan, informally known as a poison pill, for two additional years. But most poison pills let boards ignore problems until its too late. Keep any corporation independent and free from outside control. Webmd extends its poison pill defense the new york times. The poison pill device 2011 edition securities law handbook series on. There is a double meaning here as the drug company set up for takeover is forced to recall all of their most popular medication when it causes several deaths. The list of companies targeted by the california state teachers fund includes longs drug stores corp. A defensive strategy based on issuing special stock that is used to deter aggressors in corporate takeover attempts.
Adopting a poison pill in response to shareholder activism. The poison pill is a defensive strategy used against corporate takeovers. The poison pill, one of the most popular corporatetakeover defenses of the past two decades, is getting tougher to swallow. Mylan, a nasdaqquoted dutch public limited liability company or, dutch n. Even by their own terms, defense studies produced weak and inconsistent results, and failed to discriminate among information effects of defense adoptions. Poison pill academic dictionaries and encyclopedias. Poison pills will frequently increase the cost of the takeover beyond what the acquirer is willing or able to pay. Papa johns adopts poison pill defense against john schnatter. Elan finds creative poison pill to defend against a hostile.
Hostile takeover defenses poison pill the business professor. Hostile takeover meaning, examples how this strategy work. Could these 3 companies force groupon to swallow its. This strategy also acts as a tool to slow down the speed of potential. Takeover defenses and wealth effects on securityholders. Such defenses are meant to make hostile takeovers prohibitively expensive for unwanted suitors. The poison pill antitakeover defense question, but empirical testing cannot measure the loss of opportunity that might result from driving away potential bidders. Poison pill defense bodes ill for shareholders, sec. Hostile takeover learn about hostile takeover strategies. There are several defenses that the management of the target company can employ to deter a hostile takeover. A poison pill is a popular defense mechanism for a target company wherein it uses shareholders right issue as a tactic to make the hostile acquisition deal expensive or less attractive for the raiders. Jun 08, 2016 hostile takeover defenses poison pill the business professor. Using shareholder rights plans poison pills to fight takeovers.
The poison pill device contains the strategies needed to avoid hostile takeovers by utilizing shareholders rights plans, or poison pills. However, despite being one of the most effective antitakeover devices of recent times, we are witnessing an increase in shareholders activism against poison pills and increasing trend by large companies to shed their poison pills, and increasing trend by smaller companies to adopt the practice. Note also that the distinction between pre and postoffer defenses is becoming murky as increasingly poison pill plans are put in place immediately following the announcement of a bid. Poison pill definition is a financial tactic or provision used by a company to make an unwanted takeover prohibitively expensive or less desirable. This is the first study to examine the valuation effects of any antitakeover amendment on both bondholders and stockholders. With a takeover bid, the acquirer typically offers cash, stock, or a mix of both, bidding a. Proxy advisory firms, such as institutional shareholder services inc. The poison pill takeover defense, adopted by corporate directors to boost their companys price tag in a hostile takeover battle, tends to be poison for the companys shareholders as well as for. Another example, a poison pill can easily lose its effect if the acquirer wins a proxy fight for the target and then redeems the pill.
May 19, 2006 poison pill defense kept alive in eu may 19, 2006 brussels the european union is set to enact a lessrestrictive law that would leave in place poison pills and other defenses against. Oct 19, 2012 webmd has fortified its takeover defenses, as the beleaguered online health information provider continues to struggle with a falling stock price and profits. Poison pill ultimate weapon against hostile takeovers. Poison pill is a term referring to any strategy, generally in business or politics, to increase the likelihood of negative results over positive ones for a party that attempts any kind of takeover. Jun 06, 20 the main reason is that the states where american companies are organized freely allow companies to adopt takeover defenses, like a poison pill. The table contains a brief description of the defense and its defensive impact, whether shareholder. The above hostile takeover techniques and defenses show the unlimited scope of power that the board enjoys in its antitakeover activity.
Poison pills will frequently increase the cost of the takeover. In particular, the shareholders rights plan is known as the poison pill when it comes to companies fighting against the acquisition. Poison pill is a companys ultimate defensive against hostile takeovers, corporate raiders. Although poison pills provide a number of benefits to corporations and investors, they can also be risky. The practice of using poison pills to fight takeover attempts has come under scrutiny both by critics and the courts in recent years for some of the following reasons. Although the broad category of takeover defenses more commonly known as shark repellents includes the traditional shareholder rights plan poison pill. A plan whereby all the firms debt becomes due if the current management is removed. Abstracts of selected poison pills, samples of relevant sec filings, poison pill proxy materials, and other materials are included in the work. This book supplies practitioners with an examination of the development and types of poison pills, and an analysis of recent judicial decisions in the area. It derives from its original meaning of a literal poison pill carried by various spies throughout history, taken when discovered to eliminate the possibility of being interrogated for the enemys gain. Poison pill definition of poison pill by merriamwebster. Papa johns is preparing for a fight against john schnatter, the pizza chains founder and former chairman, by adopting a socalled poison pill defense to protect itself against a hostile.
A company targeted for a takeover uses a poison pill strategy to make shares of the. In response, boards of directors have adopted a variety of defensive measures including deploying the poison pill shareholder rights plan against activists. In effect, it is an agreement adopted by a companys. Poison pill poison pill the poison pill is a structural maneuver designed to thwart attempted takeovers, where the target company seeks to make itself less desirable to potential acquirers. Subramanian, supra note 3, at 625 the poison pill is by far the most important defense today. Jul 23, 2018 papa johns is preparing for a fight against john schnatter, the pizza chains founder and former chairman, by adopting a socalled poison pill defense to protect itself against a hostile. Pills can be adopted without a shareholder vote because they are issued as a dividend and the board has the exclusive authority to issue dividends. Several plan to submit resolutions designed to kill poison pill defenses. Mar 22, 2017 in response, boards of directors have adopted a variety of defensive measures including deploying the poison pill shareholder rights plan against activists. Elan finds creative poison pill to defend against a.
Theory, evidence, and policy, 1 professors lucian arye bebchuk, john c. Is hps poison pill defense against xerox toxic for. The list of companies targeted by the california state teachers fund. Apr 28, 2017 poison pill an anti takeover plan devised to automatically be activated when the company gets bought over in an unfriendly takeover. Takeover defenses are designed either to slow the takeover process and give the target firm a chance to strengthen its existing defense or put new ones in place, or raise the total cost to the acquirers of taking over the target. A shareholder rights plan, colloquially known as a poison pill, is a type of defensive tactic used by a corporations board of directors against a takeover in the field of mergers and acquisitions, shareholder rights plans were devised in the early 1980s as a way to prevent takeover bidders from negotiating a price for sale of shares directly with shareholders, and instead forcing the.
On the use of poison pills and defensive payouts by. We present new evidence documenting that, on average, there is a significant wealth loss experienced by bondholders at poison pill adoption announcement, while stockholders are unaffected. Popularly known as corporate raiding, takeovers are hostile mergers intended to acquire a corporation. A poison pill is a tactic utilized by companies to prevent or discourage hostile takeovers. But ireland, like britain, takes a different approach. Poison pill an antitakeover plan devised to automatically be activated when the company gets bought over in an unfriendly takeover. The poison pill technique, sometimes also known as a shareholder rights plan, is a form of defense against a potential hostile takeover takeover bid a takeover bid refers to the purchase of a company the target by another company the acquirer. Webmd has fortified its takeover defenses, as the beleaguered online health information provider continues to struggle with a falling stock price and profits the company said on friday that it had extended a shareholder rights plan, informally known as a poison pill, for two additional years. A shareholders rights plan is an example of a poison pill that gives existing shareholders the. Could these 3 companies force groupon to swallow its poison pill. Papa johns adopts poison pill defense against john.
We provide a comprehensive policy and doctrinal analysis of the use of poison pills again activists in corporate governance contests. On the use of poison pills and defensive payouts by takeover targets i. Other arguments favouring the use of the poison pill are also the controversial poison pill takeover defense. A poison pill is a common defensive tactic used by target companies to discourage an acquirer from their hostile takeover attempts. Limitations on the ability to call special meetings or take action by written consent. The plan which will last from april 10, 2020 to march 10, 2021. Takeover bid a takeover bid refers to the purchase of a company the target by another company the acquirer. The poison pill technique, sometimes also known as a shareholder rights plan, is a form of defense against a potential hostile takeover. The importance of a welldrafted shareholders agreement is often critical when defending against a hostile takeover. Hostile takeover of safeway could be in the offing with activist hedge fund jana partners taking a 6. A shareholder rights plan, also known as a poison pill, is one of the most effective defense tactics available to publicly traded corporations.
The more power requires the higher degree of responsibility therefore. Two decades of research on poison pills and other takeover defenses does not support the belief common among legal academics that defenses reduce firm value. The dutch poison pill received this extraordinary attention because of its use by mylan n. A poison pill is designed to make the transaction being pursued by a hostile bidder extremely unattractive from an economic perspective, compelling the bidder to negotiate with the targets board of. Aggressive takeover defenses give boards breathing space, but dont always help investors. In the powerful antitakeover force of staggered boards.
Poison pill a shareholder rights plan to prevent hostile. The main reason is that the states where american companies are organized freely allow companies to adopt takeover defenses, like a poison pill. Poison pill defense kept alive in eu may 19, 2006 brussels the european union is set to enact a lessrestrictive law that would leave in place poison pills and other defenses against. Jul, 2014 poison pill is a companys ultimate defensive against hostile takeovers, corporate raiders. The third reason for takeover defenses, managerial selfinterest, benefits the stockholders only if resistance happens by chance to be the appropriate action for one of the first two reasons. It provides the mechanics, procedures, and key drafting language, plus realworld examples to illustrate the ins and outs of this strategy. Dec 01, 2015 the dutch poison pill received this extraordinary attention because of its use by mylan n. The poison pill device 2011 edition securities law handbook series. Two law professors argue that the ubiquitous poison pill used to defend against hostile takeovers is vulnerable to being challenged as unconstitutional. Feb 12, 2020 a poison pill is a common defensive tactic used by target companies to discourage an acquirer from their hostile takeover attempts.
Hps defense against xerox is neither the first or the worst. Faced with opposition from activist shareholders and new pressures to. Mar 25, 2014 two law professors argue that the ubiquitous poison pill used to defend against hostile takeovers is vulnerable to being challenged as unconstitutional. Antitakeover defensive tactics download ebook pdf, epub. Poison pill defense kept alive in eu the new york times. This seems to ignore how negotiating power and leverage actually work in the real world. Even poster child airgas doesnt provide a knockout case. An overview of takeover defenses national bureau of.
581 1453 1309 878 1370 1204 1057 1251 604 424 287 513 363 1492 322 1009 749 1143 1206 396 158 1458 1312 452 207 1497 123 191 1341 994 1488 923 640 882 962 163 1444 299 1294 354 119 1165 453 359 219 1230 1455 411